Spooky Ghostly Pizza Bagels That Haunt Taste Buds

Every Halloween, my kitchen turns into a spooky snack factory, and these ghostly pizza bagels have become our must-make tradition. I remember the first time my niece helped me arrange the olive eyes – we laughed so hard at our lopsided ghost faces that we nearly forgot to bake them! These adorable snacks combine everything I love: quick prep (because who has time when you’re also carving pumpkins?), gooey melted cheese, and that perfect Halloween spirit. They’re the kind of recipe that makes kids squeal with delight and adults sneak seconds when they think no one’s looking. Trust me, once you try these, you’ll want to haunt your kitchen every October just to make them again!

Why You’ll Love These Ghostly Pizza Bagels

These spooky little snacks are absolute game-changers for Halloween. Here’s why they’ve haunted our recipe box for years:

• Lightning-fast prep – You can whip up a whole tray in under 15 minutes (perfect for last-minute party prep!)
• Kid magnet – Let little hands decorate their own ghost faces – messy creations taste best
• Endlessly customizable – Swap veggies based on what’s in your fridge (zucchini mouths? Why not!)
• Secretly wholesome – They’re getting veggies and protein while thinking it’s pure fun food

Ingredients for Ghostly Pizza Bagels

Here’s what you’ll need to summon these adorable little ghosts to your Halloween table. I always double check my ingredients before starting – nothing worse than realizing you’re out of olives when you’re halfway through making ghost faces!

• 4 bagels – plain or everything bagels work great (slice them in half horizontally before starting)
• 1 cup pizza sauce – my secret is using the jarred stuff for convenience, but homemade works too
• 2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese – the meltier the better for that perfect ghostly drape
• 20 slices black olives – pitted and sliced about ¼-inch thick for the eyes (about 2 cans’ worth)
• 1 bell pepper – any color, cut into tiny triangular pieces for those spooky mouths

Pro tip: Keep a few extra olives and pepper pieces handy – some always disappear during assembly (possibly due to sneaky kitchen ghosts… or hungry helpers).

Equipment You’ll Need

No fancy gadgets required for these little ghosts! Here’s what you’ll want to grab from your kitchen:

• Baking sheet – I like to line mine with parchment for easy cleanup
• Sharp knife – for slicing bagels and shaping those spooky mouths
• Cutting board – gives you space to assemble your ghost army

That’s seriously it – the beauty of this recipe is how little equipment it needs!

How to Make Ghostly Pizza Bagels

Alright, let’s bring these adorable little ghosts to life! I promise it’s easier than trying to keep track of sugar-hyped kids on Halloween night. Follow these steps, and you’ll have a tray full of spooky smiles in no time.

Preparing the Bagels

First, preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C) – this gives it time to get properly spooky-hot while you assemble everything. Take your bagel halves and arrange them on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Now, here’s my trick: spread about 2 tablespoons of pizza sauce on each half, going all the way to the edges but leaving just a tiny border so it doesn’t drip too much. If you’re feeling fancy, you can even use the back of a spoon to make little swirls in the sauce!

Creating the Ghost Faces

This is where the magic happens! Sprinkle a generous handful of mozzarella over each sauced bagel half – enough to cover completely but not so much that it avalanches off. Now for the fun part: place two olive slices about 1 inch apart near the top for eyes. Press them in gently so they don’t roll off. For the mouth, take your bell pepper triangles and arrange them in a cute little “O” shape or a wavy spooky smile underneath the eyes. Pro tip: blot your olives and peppers with a paper towel first – drier toppings stick better to the cheese!

Baking Instructions

Slide your ghostly creations into the preheated oven and bake for 10-12 minutes. You’ll know they’re ready when the cheese is fully melted with those perfect golden bubbles forming, and the edges of the bagels get just slightly crisp. Keep an eye on them after the 8-minute mark – oven ghosts can be tricky! Let them cool for about 2 minutes before serving (unless you want melty cheese mustaches on your little monsters). The cheese will set slightly as it cools, keeping those olive eyes perfectly in place.

Tips for Perfect Ghostly Pizza Bagels

After making these spooky snacks more times than I can count (and fixing plenty of “ghostly mishaps”), here are my foolproof tricks:

• Blot those olives dry – Wet toppings slide right off melted cheese! I keep a stack of paper towels ready during assembly.
• Preheat your baking sheet – Pop it in the oven as it warms up for extra-crispy bottoms.
• Go easy on the sauce – Too much makes soggy ghosts. Just enough to cover without pooling.
• Bake lower longer – If your ghosts keep getting too dark, try 350°F for 15 minutes instead.

Bonus: Store extra olive eyes and pepper mouths in a baggie – they make great fridge snacks while you wait for the bagels to bake!

Creative Variations for Ghostly Pizza Bagels

Once you’ve mastered the classic ghost faces, it’s time to get creative! Here are some of my favorite ways to haunt up this recipe:

• Monster mash-up – Swap mozzarella for orange cheddar to make pumpkin ghosts, or use purple potatoes for Frankenstein faces
• Veggie ghosts – Try zucchini mouths or jalapeño slices for spicy little spirits (kids love the “boo-urns” pun!)
• Meaty apparitions – Pepperoni eyebrows or crumbled sausage “hairstyles” add protein-packed personality

The best part? Every Halloween brings new spooky inspiration – last year we made vampire bagels with fangs from garlic cloves!

Serving Suggestions for Ghostly Pizza Bagels

These little ghosts deserve a spooky spread to match! Try serving them with a bowl of warm marinara for dipping (extra “blood” sauce, anyone?). For drinks, pair with eerie green limeade or orange soda “punch” – just add gummy worms! They also make perfect companions to mummy hot dogs or creepy-crawly cheese platters at Halloween parties.

Storing and Reheating Ghostly Pizza Bagels

These ghostly goodies taste best fresh, but if you have leftovers (a rare occurrence in my house!), here’s how to keep them spookily delicious: Store cooled bagels in an airtight container for up to 2 days in the fridge. When ready to revive your ghosts, pop them in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes – microwaving makes them soggy and causes those adorable olive eyes to slide off!

Nutritional Information for Ghostly Pizza Bagels

These nutrition facts are estimates based on standard ingredients – your ghosts may vary slightly! Each spooky bagel half contains approximately:

• 220 calories
• 8g fat
• 28g carbs
• 9g protein

Perfect for fueling your Halloween mischief without haunting your diet!

Frequently Asked Questions About Ghostly Pizza Bagels

Over the years, I’ve gotten all sorts of questions about these spooky snacks – here are the answers to the ones that pop up most often!

Can I use different cheeses?

Absolutely! While mozzarella gives that classic pizza flavor and perfect melt, I’ve had great results with Monterey Jack for extra creaminess or a provolone-mozzarella mix. For a sharper taste, try white cheddar – just know it won’t stretch quite as dramatically. Avoid super dry cheeses like parmesan though – they tend to make ghost faces look more “zombified” than cute!

How far in advance can I assemble these?

You can prep these ghosts about 2 hours before baking if you need to. Just assemble them on the tray, cover loosely with plastic wrap, and keep in the fridge until ready to bake. Any longer and the bagels might get soggy. I prefer prepping toppings separately and doing final assembly right before baking for crispiest results.

Are there nut-free alternatives for school parties?

For nut-free classrooms, I swap regular bagels for English muffins – same great pizza base without the allergy concerns! You could also use thick slices of French bread or even halved whole wheat pitas. The ghosts might look a little different, but they’ll still charm the lunchroom!

Share Your Spooky Creations!

Did you make these ghostly pizza bagels? I’d love to see your hauntingly creative variations! Tag your photos with #GhostlyPizzaBagels so we can all admire your spooky snack masterpieces. Happy haunting, fellow foodies! You can also find more Halloween recipe inspiration on Pinterest.

Print